Review and analysis of the collision incident between Cargo Ship Edmy and Fishing Vessel Tornado: Extracting lessons from a case
List of Authors
  • Amir Syawal Kamis , Nurul Aqilah Insyirah Mohd Hayrulnizam

Keyword
  • Navigation, Safety, Marine Accident, Case Review, Lesson Learned

Abstract
  • This study reviews an investigation report that involves collision incident between the Cargo Ship Edmy and the Fishing Vessel Tornado. After conducting a thorough analysis of the incident, it was concluded that the collision occurred due to a confluence of factors, namely excessive dependence on navigation equipment and inadequate utilisation of the navigation tools at hand. Consequently, a number of valuable insights have been identified with the aim of improving maritime safety. The study highlights the significance of evaluating and enhancing watchkeeping protocols. This encompasses the establishment of the minimum prerequisites for bridge configuration and surveillance in diverse sailing situations, with the aim of guaranteeing sufficient attentiveness and proactive navigation. Additionally, the research emphasises the importance of establishing the closest point of approach and time to the closest point of approach parameters within Automatic Radar Plotting Aids. The implementation of these values and their prominent placement in close proximity to radars, coupled with the incorporation of alarms within the Automatic Radar Plotting Aid system, serves to augment the level of awareness among bridge personnel pertaining to the importance of upholding appropriate separation distances to ensure safety. The study underscores the importance of improving the standing orders of the master. This entails the revision of the standing orders to incorporate the insights gained, which includes the proscription of engaging in paperwork or utilising autonomous equipment in the absence of a backup lookout. The study endeavours to enhance safety practises and mitigate the occurrence of comparable incidents in the future by examining and addressing the lessons derived from them. This highlights the significance of striking a harmonious equilibrium between the utilisation of navigation equipment as valuable instruments, while simultaneously upholding the ongoing dependence on human judgement, sustaining situational awareness, and adhering to appropriate navigation protocols.

Reference
  • 1. Ahmad Faizal, A. F., Hatun, M. K., Kamis, A. S., Akash, M. D., & Mohd Sharifuddin, A. (2023). Study on traffic and probability of collision at navigation channel of the top three ports in Study on Traffic and Probability of Collision at Navigation Channel of the Top Three Ports in Malaysia. AIP Conference Proceedings, 040001(February). 2. Ahmad Fuad, A. F., Anwar, A. Q., Ahmad, M. S., Said, M. H., & Kamis, A. S. (2022). Development of an International Framework for Private Maritime Security Companies in Malaysia. In Design in Maritime Engineering. Advanced Structured Materials (pp. 431–440). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-89988-2_32 3. Haron, S. J. bin. (2015). Analysis of Marine Incidents in Malaysia. January, 1–72. 4. ICS. (2016). Bridge Procedure Guide (Fifth ed). Marisec Publications. https://marinerscircle.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Bridge-Procedure-Guide-Fifth-Edition-2016.pdf 5. Kamis, A. S., Ahmad Fuad, A. F., Anwar, A. Q., & Monir Hossain, M. (2022). A systematic scoping review on ship accidents due to off-track manoeuvring. WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs, 39. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13437-022-00274-2 6. Kamis, A. S., Ahmad Fuad, A. F., Ashaari, A., & Mohd Noor, C. W. (2021). Wheel over point mathematical model. Ocean Systems Engineering, 11(3), 203–216. https://doi.org/10.12989/ose.2021.11.3.203 7. Kamis, A. S., Ahmad Fuad, A. F., Mohd Fadzil, M. N., & Saadon, S. I. (2020). The Impact of Basic Training on Seafarers’ Safety Knowledge , Attitude and Behaviour. Journal of Sustainability Science and Management, 15(6), 137–158. https://doi.org/10.46754/jbsd.2020.08.012 8. Malterud, K., Siersma, V. D., & Guassora, A. D. (2016). Sample Size in Qualitative Interview Studies: Guided by Information Power. Qualitative Health Research, 26(13), 1753–1760. https://doi.org/10.1177/1049732315617444 9. NIMA. (2001). Radar Navigation And Maneuvering Board Manual. http://msi.nga.mil/NGAPortal/MSI.portal?_nfpb=true&_st=&_pageLabel=msi_portal_page_62&pubCode=0008 10. NSIA. (2022). Collision between the cargo ship ‘ Edmy ’ and the fishing vessel ‘Tornado’ outside Langesund on 4 October 2022. December, 1–9. https://safety4sea.com/nsia-investigation-too-much-reliance-on-navigational-aids-leads-to-collision/ 11. OSHA. (2015). Incident (Accident) Investigations: A Guide for Employers. United States Department of Labor - Occupational Safety and Health Administration. https://www.osha.gov/sites/default/files/IncInvGuide4Empl_Dec2015.pdf 12. Swift, A. J. (2018). Bridge team management: A practical guide (2nd Ed.). Nautical Institute. 13. Wu, J., Thorne-Large, J., & Zhang, P. (2021). Safety first: The risk of over-reliance on technology in navigation. Journal of Transportation Safety & Security, 1–28. https://doi.org/10.1080/19439962.2021.1909681 14. Μακεδονιασ, Α. Ε. Ν. (2015). BRIDGE PROCEDURES - MASTER STANDING ORDERS. https://maredu.hcg.gr/modules/document/file.php/MAK265/Dissertations in English/Bridge Procedures%2CMaster Standing Orders.pdf