The Malaysian Employees Provident Fund's members' investment scheme: survey of fund selection, performance and perceptions
List of Authors
  • Jidwin, Agnes Paulus

Keyword
  • Employees Provident Funds, Members Investment Scheme, Unit Trust, Performance and Perceptions, Structural Survey Analysis

Abstract
  • This study examines whether the Employee Provident Fund members investment scheme (EPF-MIS) introduced by EPF could provide better performance than the EPF retirement plan itself. Statistics have revealed that the average retirement savings of EPF members currently are inadequate and many members may find themselves with insufficient funds if the issue of adequacy of savings is not addressed. To partly address the above-mentioned issues, EPF introduced the investment withdrawal scheme in 1996 to enhance retirement savings. However, participating members were concerned when it was reported that members had suffered losses of about RM600 million in unit trust investments, contradicting the good performance of the unit trust funds industry. Thus, this paper attempts to revisit these issues by conducting a structural survey analysis on EPF members’ investment in unit trusts, based on strategies, unit trust performance and members’ perceptions. This study involved 310 respondents, covering all states in Malaysia. Collectively, findings revealed that members’ experiences of investment performances in unit trusts were mixed. The highest return on members’ investment was 10% and lowest return was negative 5%. This provides evidence to show that there are possibilities of the participating members’ earnings falling below the 2.5% guaranteed minimum return for EPF. From the opportunistic point of view, there are also possibilities for members to generate higher returns than the average performance of EPF investment of 5% with appropriate fund selection strategies as discussed in this paper. It is concluded that members’ investment performance is influenced by their level of knowledge of unit trust investment, information source as well as fund selection criteria. Additionally, financial consultants play a critical role in assisting EPF members with their investment decision making, since the majority of them are relying on services and advice rendered by financial consultants. Recommendations are drawn on EPF members’ perceptions and industry best practices, and given for future research.

Reference
  • A. Samad, F. (2003). Survival after Retirement: Will Employees Provident Funds’ (EPF) Savings is Able to Provide a Comfortable Retirement? Akauntan Nasional, 16 (2), Issue March 2003.
    Bala, R., and Matthew C.H.Y. (2003). Evaluating Mutual Funds in an Emerging Market: Factors That Matter to Financial Advisors, International Journal of Bank Marketing, 21 (3), 122-136.
    Bruce A. H. (2005). Does Mutual Fund Advertising Provide Necessary Investment Information? International Journal of Bank Marketing, 23 (4), 296-316.
    Cheng-Ru, W., Hsin-Yuan, C., and Li-Syuan, W. (2008). A Framework of Assessable Mutual Fund Performance, Journal of Modelling in Management, 3 (2), 125-139.
    Charles A. Trzcinka (1998). Mutual Fund Fees and Competition in the Mutual Fund Industry. Available at www.kelley.iu.edu/ctrzcink.
    Collins, S. (2003). The Expenses of Defined Benefits Pension Plans and Mutual Funds, Investment Company Institute Journal, 9 (6), 1-19.
    David Richardson (2004). Variety Characterises Asian Pensions Funding, The Investment Management Perspectives, Issue July 2004, 63-70.Available at http://www.pwc.com/en_GX/gx/investment-management-real-estate/pdf/0704perspectives.pdf.
    Employees Provident Fund Annual Reports (various years).
    Firkiyah, A., Shamsher, M., and Taufiq, H. (2001). A Comparative Performance of Malaysian Islamic and Conventional Mutual Funds, Managerial Finance, 33(2), 142-153.
    Gary P. Brinson, Brian D. Singer and Gilbert L. Beebower (1991). Determinants of Portfolio Performance II: An Update, Financial Analysts Journal, 47 (3), 40-48.
    Gruber, Martin, J. (1996). Another Puzzle: The Growth in Actively Managed Mutual Funds, The Journal of Finance, 51 (3), 783-810.
    Hussein A. Hassan Al-Tamimi and Al Anood, K. (2009). Financial Literacy and Investment Decisions of UAE Investors, The Journal of Risk Finance, 10(5), 500-516.
    Ippolito, Richard. A (1989). Efficiency with Costly Information. A Study of Mutual Fund Performance, 1965 – 1984, The Quarterly Journal of Economic, 104 (1), 1-23.
    Jeffrey Gan (2007). The Untold Million-Dollar Secrets of Unit Trust Investment. Leeds Publication: Selangor, Malaysia.
    John Nuttall, William Jahnke, Roger G. Ibbotson and Paul D. Kaplan (2000). Does Asset Allocation Policy Explain 40, 90, or 100 Percent of Performance? Financial Analysts Journal, 56 (1), 26-3322.
    Joseph H.H. Chia and Y.K.Tse (2000). An Empirical Analysis of Unit Trust Performance in Singapore, School of Business, Singapore Management University. Available at http://staff.mysmu.edu/yktse/ChiaTse_1.pdf.
    Lee Boon Keng and Andy Ong (2004), Personal Financial Planning in Malaysia. AFPJ Pte. Ltd.,: Singapore.
    Lee Hock Lock (2001). Financial Security in Old Age: Whither the Employees Provident Funds of Malaysia. Pelanduk Publication: Selangor, Malaysia.
    M. Taib, F., and Isa, M. (2007). Malaysian Unit Trust Aggregate Performance, Journal of Managerial Finance, 33 (2), 102-121.
    M. Nor, A.R. (2009). Statistical Methods in Research. Malaysia: Prentice Hall.
    Micheal, A. Firth (1977). The Investment Performance of Unit Trusts in the Period of 1965 – 1975, Money Credit and Banking Journal, 9 (4), 597-604.
    Michael, C. Jensen (1968). Problem in Selection in Security Portfolios. The Performance of Mutual Funds in the Period of 1954 – 1964, The Journal of Finance, 23, (2), 389-416.
    Miguel A. Ferreira, António F. Miguel and Ramos, S. (2006). The Determinants of Mutual Fund Performance: A Cross-Country Study, Swiss Finance Institute Research Paper Series, 6-31. Available at http://ideas.repec.org/f/pra296.html.
    Narayanan, S (2002). Old Age Support For Private Sector Employees in Malaysia: Can The Employees Provident Fund Do Better? Hitotsubashi Journal of Economics, 43, 119-134.
    Nawawi, A.H., Mehad, S., Hassan, R, A. Rahman, H. (2000). A Performance Evaluation of Unit Trust Industry in Malaysia, BRC Journal, 6 (1), 97-123.
    Noel C., Gavan J., and Rick W. (1994). Affluent Investors and Mutual Fund Purchases, International Journal of Bank Marketing, 12(3), 17-25.
    Roger Otten and Dennis Bams (2007). The Performance of Local versus Foreign Mutual Fund Managers, European Financial Management, 13 (4), 702-720.
    Shamsher M. and Annuar M.N (1995). Performance of Unit Trusts in Malaysia: Some Evidence, Capital Market Review 3, 51-64.
    Soo-Wah, Low (2007). Malaysian Unit Trust Funds’ Performance During Up and Down Market Conditions: A comparison of market benchmark, Managerial Finance, 33(2), 154-166.
    Thillainathan, R. (2004). Malaysia: Pension & Financial Market Reforms and Key Issues on Government. Paper Presented at the Conference on Pension in Asia organized by Hitotsubashi University in Tokyo. Available at http://hermes-ir.lib.hit- u.ac.jp/rs/bitstream/10086/14293/1/pie_dp197.pdf.
    Tng, C.S (2006). Factors Influencing Unit Trust Performance, DBA thesis, Southern Cross University, Lismore, NSW. Available at http://epubs.scu.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1046&context=theses 23.
    William, F. Sharpe (1996). Mutual Fund Performance, Journal of Business, 39, (1), 119-138.
    William G. Droms and David A. Walker (1996). Mutual Funds Performance, The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 36 (3), 347-363.
    Wee-Yeap, L. (2007). An Integrated Framework for Style Analysis: How is It Useful to Malaysian Equity Trust Investors? Managerial Finance, 33(2), 122-141.
    Yahaya, A., Yahaya, N., Mohamad, R.A., Ramli, J., Boon, Y., A. Ghaffar, M.N., and Zakariya, Z. (2009). National Unit Trust Berhad (NUTB) Promotional Strategies for Bumiputra in Malaysia, American Journal of Scientific Research, 5, 33-49.
    Yeo, K.S (2003). Investing Your Savings, Star Publications Berhad, Malaysia.
    Yin-Fah, B.C., Paim, L., Masud, J, and Hamid, T.A. (2010). The Future of the Malaysian Older Employees: An Exploratory Study, International Journal of Business management, 5 (4), 125-132.