Asymmetrical federalism and anti-federal sentiment in Malaysia: the Sabah experience
List of Authors
  • Mohammad Agus Yusoff , Mohammad Azziyadi Ismail

Keyword
  • Asymmetrical federalism, anti-federal, Malaysia Agreement 1963, Central Government, Sabah

Abstract
  • Federalism is a system of fair and orderly power sharing between the state and federal governments. However, in the case of the Federation of Malaysia, this division is unbalanced and asymmetrical, owing to the fact that Sabah and Sarawak have been given more privileges than other states in Malaya as a condition to join the Federation of Malaysia during its formation on 16 September 1963. These terms were proposed by the Intergovernmental Committee and included in the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (MA63), which was signed on July 9, 1963, in London by the United Kingdom, the Federation of Malaya (Malaya), North Borneo (Sa-bah), Sarawak, and Singapore. Despite the fact that MA63 and the 20-point Agreement grant Sabah unique privileges, the state has long struggled with federalism issues, giving rise to anti-federal sentiments. Using the concept of asymmetrical federalism as a tool of analysis, this study examines the issues of asymmetrical fed-eralism responsible for the anti-federal sentiment in Sabah. Interviews were used to collect primary data, while sources including books, journals, newspapers and online news were mined for secondary data in this quali-tative study. Oil royalties, unequal development between Sabah and the Peninsula, immigration and security threats, Sabah's regional status within Malaysia and Borneonisation were found to be the five main issues that prompted Sabahans to be dissatisfied with the implementation of asymmetrical federalism. The failure of the Sabah and federal governments to address these issues has contributed to the birth of anti-federal sentiment in Sabah.

Reference
  • 1. Agenda Daily (2021, 14 December). RUU Pindaan MA63 lulus dengan majoriti lebih dua pertiga. https://www.agendadaily.com/isu-semasa/ruu-pindaan-ma63-lulus-dengan-majoriti-lebih-duapertiga/
    2. Agranoff, R. (1999). Power shifts, diversity and asymmetry. In Robert Agranoff (eds.). Accommodating di-versity: asymmetry in federal states (pp. 11-23). Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft.
    3. Anwar Ibrahim (2021, 18 September). Memorandum of Understanding (MoU). Opposition leader and MP for Port Dickson, interview at his office in Jalan Gasing, Petaling Jaya.
    4. Astro Awani (2014, 15 February). Kronologi pencerobohan Lahad Datu. https://www.astroawani.com/video-politik/kronologi-pencerobohan-lahad-datu-1694650
    5. Astro Awani (2015, 14 May). Dua individu diculik di Sandakan—pengarah ESSCOM. http://www.astroa-wani.com/berita-malaysia/dua-individu-diculik-di-sandakan-pengarah-esscom-59965
    6. Astro Awani (2019a, 8 March). Kabinet setuju pinda Perkara 1(2) Perlembagaan Persekutuan—Liew. https://www.astroawani.com/berita-malaysia/setuju-pinda-perkara-1-2-perlembagaan-persekutu-anliew-201022.
    7. Astro Awani (2019b, 9 April). MA63: Kurang 10 undi, kerajaan gagal pinda Perlembagaan Persekutuan. https://www.astroawani.com/berita-malaysia/ma63-kurang-10-undi-kerajaan-gagal-pinda-per-lembagaan-persekutuan-203942.
    8. Astro Awani (2020a, 6 February). Mengapa 20 peratus royalti minyak tidak boleh dilaksanakan? Petronas beri penjelasan. https://www.astroawani.com/berita-malaysia/mengapa-20-peratus-royalti-minyak-tidak-boleh-dilaksanakan-petronas-beri-penjelasan-230057.
    9. Astro Awani (2020b, 2 November). RM61.32 bilion bayaran hasil petroleum kepada empat negeri bagi 2008-2020. https://www.astroawani.com/berita-malaysia/rm61-32-bilion-bayaran-hasil-petroleum-kepada-empat-negeri-bagi-2008-2020-266481.
    10. Astro Awani (2021, 24 January). Isu air Sabah, pengurusan air lebih cekap di Sabah.https://www.astroa-wani.com/video-malaysia/isu-air-sabah-pengurusan-air-lebih-cekap-di-sabah-1886989.
    11. Bala, B. (2018). Satu daripada tiga belas: Sabah dan Sarawak dalam pembentukan Malaysia, Jurnal Borneo Arkhailogia (Heritage, Archaeology and History) 1961-1963, 3(2), 13-52.
    12. Berita Harian (2018, 16 September). Status Sabah dan Sarawak sebagai rakan sekutu dikembalikan. https://www.bharian.com.my/berita/nasional/2018/09/ 474473/
    13. Berita Harian (2020, 27 July). RM1.25b naik taraf 237 sekolah daif di Sabah. https://www.bhar-ian.com.my/berita/nasional/2020/07/715252/rm125b-naik-taraf-237-sekolah-daif-di-sabah.
    14. Berita Harian (2021, 14 December). Pindaan Perlembagaan berkaitan MA63 diluluskan. https://www.bhar-ian.com.my/berita/nasional/2021/12/899024/ pindaan-perlembagaan-berkaitan-ma63-diluluskan
    15. Borneo Daily Bulletin (2022, 3 March). https://www.borneodailybulletin.com/ keadaan-beberapa-jalan-raya-utama-di-sabah-membimbangkan-dan-berbahaya-kepada-pengguna/
    16. Buku Harapan (2018). Membina Negara Memenuhi Harapan. https://store.ubah.my/ ManifestoPH_BM.pdf.
    17. Burgess, M. (2006). Comparative federalism: theory and practice. New York: Routledge.
    18. Chin, J. (2019). The 1963 Malaysian Agreement (MA63): Sabah and Sarawak and the politics of historical grievances. S. Lemiere (ed.). Minorities matter: Malaysian politics and people (pp. 75-92). Singapore: ISEAS-Yusuf Ishak Institute.
    19. Dewan Rakyat (2018). Jawapan Lisan YB Menteri Hal Ehwal Ekonomi. Penyata Rasmi Dewan Rakyat. 2(12): 1792-1850 Parlimen Keenam Penggal Kedua. 1-7 Parlimen Keempat Belas Penggal Pertama Mesyuarat Pertama.
    20. Dollah, R. & Abdullah, K. (2018). The securitization of migrant workers in Sabah, Malaysia. Journal of In-ternational Migration and Integration, 19(3), 717-735.
    21. Economic Planning Unit (EPU), Jabatan Perdana Menteri (JPM) (2021). Rancangan Malaysia Ke-12 (2021-2026). Kuala Lumpur: Unit Perancang Ekonomi.
    22. Harding, A. (2018). A measure of autonomy: federalism as protection for Malaysia’s indigenous peoples. Federal Law Review, 46(4), 557–574.
    23. Ismail, M.A. & Yusoff, M.A. (2022). Xenophobia and anti-federal sentiment in Sabah and its impact on Ma-laysian federalism. JATI: Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 27(1), 66-87.
    24. Jabatan Perangkaan Malaysia (DOSM) (2019). Siaran akhbar: statistik jenayah. 27 November. https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/index.php?r=column/pdfPrev&id=OWZSTkRPbGxwREp-FbjRjZ2w1OUVGUT09.
    25. Jabatan Perangkaan Malaysia (DOSM) (2020a). Laporan Sosioekonomi Sabah 2020. https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/uploads/files/1_Articles_By_Themes/National%20A counts/GDPbyState/2020/Laporan_Sosioekonomi_Sabah_2019.pdf.
    26. Jabatan Perangkaan Malaysia (DOSM) (2020b). Newsletter: Kependudukan negeri Sabah 2020. https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/uploads/files/6_0Newsletter/Newsletter%202020/DOSM_DOSM_SA-BAH_1_2020_Siri-86.pdf
    27. Inter-Governmental Committee Report (IGC) (1962). https://sagc.sabah.gov.my/sites/de-fault/files/law/IGCReport.pdf
    28. Laporan Ketua Audit Negara (LKAN) 2019. Aktiviti Kementerian/Jabatan Kerajaan Persekutuan dan Badan Berkanun Persekutuan. https://www.audit.gov.my/ images/pdf/2020/2019_S2/LKAN2019-Siri-2-Ak-tiviti-Kementerian-Persekutuan.pdf.
    29. Loh, Kok Wah (1992). Modernization, cultural revival and counter hegemony: the Kadazans of Sabah in the 1980s. Hawaii: University of Hawaii Press.
    30. Luping, H. (1994). Sabah’s dilemma: the political history of Sabah 1960-94. Kuala Lumpur: Magnus.
    31. Mahdzir Khalid, Dato Seri (2021, 26 September). Sabahan sentiment towards the federal government and development issues in Sabah. Minister of Rural Development. Interview at his office in Putrajaya.
    32. Maiz, R. & Losada, A. (2011). The erosion of regional powers in the Spanish, state of autonomies. In Requejo, F. & Nagel, K.K. (eds.). Federalism beyond federations: asymmetry and processes of resymmetrisa-tion in Europe (pp. 81-107). London: Asghgate.
    33. Malaysia Energy Statistics Handbook (2020). https://www.st.gov.my/en/contents/ files/download/116/Malay-sia_Energy_Statistics_Handbook_20201.pdf.
    34. Maximus Ongkili, Dato Seri (2022, 12 April). Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department for Sabah and Sarawak Affairs. Interview at his office, Putrajaya.
    35. Md Salleh Md. Said (2021, 19 November). Development and oil royalty issues in Sabah dan Sarawak. Former Minister of Information and Communications, and currently State Assemblyman for Usukan. Interview in Melaka during the Malacca state election campaign.
    36. Mintz, J. (2019). Two different conflicts in federal systems: an application to Canada. Calgary: University of Calgary Press.
    37. Mulia, D. S. (2009). Pekerja asing di Sabah: isu dan perspektif. In Dzurirah, I. & Balakrishnan, P. & Rosaz-man, H. (eds.). Hubungan industri dan sumber manusia. Edisi ke-2. Kota Kinabalu: Penerbit Univer-siti Malaysia Sabah.
    38. Mustapha Mohamed (2021, 7 September). The management of Malaysian economy. Minister in the Prime Minister's Department for Economic Affairs. Interview at his office in Putrajaya.
    39. Parker, P. (2014). Comparative federalism and Intergovernmental Agreements: analyzing Australia, Canada, Germany, South Africa, Switzerland and the United States. New York: Routledge.
    40. Roff, M.C. (1974). The politics of belonging: political change in Sabah and Sarawak. Kuala Lumpur: Ox-ford University Press.
    41. Sabah for Sabahan (Facebook) (2020). Berapakah royalti 5% minyak Sabah? https://www.facebook.com/Sa-bahForSabahanS4S/posts/3395920900496751.
    42. Sarawak Voice (2016, 21 October). Pindaan Perlembagaan Persekutuan pada 1976: Siapakah pemimpin politik Sarawak yang terbabit? https://sarawakvoice.com/2016/10/21/pindaan-perlembagaan-perseku-tuan-pada-1976-siapakah-pemimpin-politik-sarawak-yang-terbabit/#.
    43. Salleh, A., Puyok A. & Bagang, T. P. (2019). Constitutional symmetry in Malaysia: a case study of Sabah and Sarawak. In. P. Popelier & M. Sahadžić (eds.). Constitutional asymmetry in multinational federalism: federalism and internal conflicts (pp. 50-80). New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
    44. Sinar Harian (2020, 7 November). Peruntukan RM5.1 bilion bukti Sabah di hati kerajaan Pusat. https://www.sinarharian.com.my/article/108932/EDISI/Sabah-Sarawak/ Peruntukan- RM51-bilion-bukti-Sabah-di-hati-kerajaan-Pusat.
    45. Sinar Harian (2021, 28 November). Sabah digesa tangani isu kelemahan imigresen. https://www.sinarhar-ian.com.my/article/333277.
    46. Sinring, M. S. & Govindasamy, A.R. (2018). Sabah Sarawak eluar Malaysia (SSKM): hala tuju selepas PRU-14. Jurnal Khas Kinabalu, 411-435.
    47. Suruhanjaya Tenaga (2020). National Energy Balance 2019. NEB_2019.pdf (st.gov.my).
    48. Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman (2021, 26 September). Sabah development and the Sheraton Move. Former Minister of Youth and Sports, MUDA party president, and MP for Muar. Interview at his house in Petaling Jaya.
    49. Tarlton, C.D. (1965). Symmetry and asymmetry as elements of federalism: a theoretical speculation. The Journal of Politics, 27(4), 861-874.
    50. The Edge (2013, 16 May). The oil royalty rumble. https://www.heedgemarkets.com/article/oil-royalty-rum-ble.
    51. Tzagkas, C.A. (2018). The internal conflict in Spain: the case of Catalonia. International Journal of Latest Research in Humanities and Social Science, 1(8), 58-68.
    52. Utusan Borneo (2018, 7 April). Manifesto BN: mengukir senyuman untuk Sabah dan Sarawak. https://www.utusanborneo.com.my/2018/04/07/manifesto-bn-mengukir-senyuman-untuk-sabah-dan-sarawak.
    53. Utusan Borneo (2018, 2 October). Perlu ikhlas kembali status wilayah Sabah, Sarawak. https://www.utusanborneo.com.my/2018/10/02/perlu-ikhlas-kembali-status-wilayah-sabah-sarawak.
    54. Utusan Malaysia (2021, 15 August). Warisan, MUDA, PSB, UPKO tolak tawaran Perdana Menteri. https://www.utusan.com.my/berita/2021/08/warisan-muda-psb-upko-tolak-tawaran-perdana-men-teri/.
    55. Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar (2022, 6 January). Law issues, Borneo development, and oil royalties in Sabah and Sarawak. Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department in charge of Parliament and Law. Inter-view at his office in Putrajaya.
    56. Webb, M.J. (2012). Kashmir’s right to secede: a critical examination of contemporary theories of secession. New York: Routledge.
    57. Yeoh, T. (2019). Reviving the spirit of federalism: decentralisation policy option for a New Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: IDEAS Policy Research.
    58. Yusoff, M.A. (2002). Politik federalisme di Malaysia: pengalaman Sabah. Journal of Southeast Asian Stud-ies 7(1), 1-20.
    59. Yusoff, M. A. (2006). Malaysian federalism: conflict or consensus. Bangi: Penerbit Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.